Al-Hakim al-Naysaburi and His al-Mustadrak
Dr Mahmud Mira
- pages
- 507
- Size
- 62.4 MB
- File language
- العربية
- Published
- October 7, 2026
- reads
- 36
- downloads
- 8
- saves
- 0
About this book
“Al-Hakim al-Naysaburi and His al-Mustadrak ala al-Sahihayn,” by Dr Mahmud Mira, is a specialized hadith study of Imam Abu Abd Allah al-Hakim al-Naysaburi and his al-Mustadrak. It combines a biography of the author with an examination of the book’s critical and applied method. The study covers al-Hakim’s scholarly life, teachers, students, standing among hadith scholars, and writings. It then examines why he compiled al-Mustadrak, how he arranged its reports, what he meant by “sound according to the criteria of the two Shaykhs,” “according to al-Bukhari’s criteria,” or “according to Muslim’s criteria,” and how consistently he applied those criteria. A central part of the book compares al-Hakim’s hadith gradings with those of other critics, identifying where he was accurate and where he was lenient. It also discusses al-Dhahabi’s corrections and the widely repeated description of al-Hakim as lenient in declaring reports sound. The study therefore evaluates his method through the reports themselves rather than merely introducing al-Mustadrak. The book also explains al-Mustadrak’s place among the collections of the Prophetic Sunnah. The presence of weak, very weak, or fabricated reports does not erase its scholarly value: it contains extensive hadith material, chains, additional reports, and important routes. Yet al-Hakim’s gradings cannot be accepted solely on his authority; they require examination and comparison with the principles of hadith scholarship. This study is useful to readers seeking to understand al-Hakim as a critic, the actual method of al-Mustadrak, his use of the two Shaykhs’ criteria, the extent of the leniency attributed to him, and how hadith scholars handled his gradings and al-Dhahabi’s corrections.