Al-Tahrir wa-l-Idah on the Defects in the Hadith of Guardianship in Marriage
Abd Allah ibn Yusuf al-Juday
- pages
- 260
- Size
- 10.2 MB
- File language
- العربية
- Published
- October 13, 2026
- reads
- 5
- downloads
- 1
- saves
- 0
About this book
Al-Tahrir wa-l-Idah fi Ilal Hadith al-Wilayah fi al-Nikah by Abd Allah ibn Yusuf al-Juday is an extensive critical study of hadiths on guardianship in marriage, especially “There is no marriage without a guardian.” The author gathers its routes from the Companions, studies the chains and defects, examines differences in connected versus disconnected transmission and attribution to the Prophet versus a Companion, and weighs early critics’ opinions against later judgments. He resolves points of disagreement and distinguishes established wording from unsound additions. The author concludes that “There is no marriage without a guardian” is sound, established through reports from Abu Musa al-Ashari, Aishah, and Abu Hurayrah, with a supporting route from Jabir. The book highlights the importance of consulting hadith criticism and critics’ judgments, without being misled by numerous routes or turning authentication and weakening into tools for defending a legal school.