Al-Abatil: Critical Study of False and Unfounded Hadiths
Dr Kacem Khailat
- pages
- 100
- Size
- 1.7 MB
- File language
- العربية
- Published
- October 7, 2026
- reads
- 16
- downloads
- 3
- saves
- 0
About this book
Al-Abatil by Professor Dr Kacem Khailat is a critical hadith work defending the Prophetic Sunnah by examining reports falsely attributed to the Prophet, especially those widely circulated among the public, preachers, in books, and in sermons. The author states that the book belongs to his studies of hadith and its hidden defects, and that he follows the approach of early hadith critics: gathering the routes of a report, examining differences among transmitters, uncovering defects, and weighing the evidence—not relying merely on many routes or a report’s popularity. The book covers not only technically fabricated reports but also rejected, false, weak, and baseless material, unpreserved additions, and reports commonly attributed to the Prophet that are actually Companion statements or disconnected transmissions. It explains the reasons for these attribution errors. Rather than giving bare verdicts, the author investigates solitary transmission, contradiction, interruption, tadlis, narrator confusion, and transmitter mistakes, compares versions, and prefers preserved material over anomalous reports. He sometimes addresses legal questions built on reports of disputed authenticity, including the call to prayer in a newborn’s ear, writing on graves, the prayer of need, reciting Surat al-Kahf on Friday night, and the timing of cupping, distinguishing a report’s authenticity from the legal ruling based on it. The work also critiques popular reports and sayings, including “This is a hand loved by God and His Messenger,” “Treat your sick by giving charity,” and “Keep your needs secret,” tracing their routes without being swayed by fame or multiple sources when those routes cannot support one another. This applied study of hadith defects and report criticism aims to distinguish preserved material from later intrusion, return reports to their sources, and revive early critics’ method of weighing all relevant evidence rather than relying on the apparent chain alone.