Al-Mankhul: Distinguishing Sound Hadiths from Unfounded Reports
Dr Kacem Khailat
- pages
- 107
- Size
- 0.8 MB
- File language
- العربية
- Published
- October 7, 2026
- reads
- 11
- downloads
- 2
- saves
- 0
About this book
Al-Mankhul: Tamyiz al-Sahih min al-Madkhul by Professor Dr Kacem Khailat is a critical hadith work and the third volume in his series of hadith studies. It examines reports, sayings, and stories circulated by preachers and on social media that are not established from the Prophet or the Companions, distinguishing sound, weak, false, and baseless material. The book does more than collect fabricated reports. It treats reports with differing grades: beginning with a circulating wording, it searches for its source and routes, studies chains, narrators, and transmission paths, cites critics when needed, and reaches a reasoned judgment. It may show that a famous wording is false although its meaning is sound in another hadith, or that a weak report has an authentic alternative in the same subject. The author focuses on hidden defects, solitary transmission, contradiction, interrupted transmission, narrator confusion, and transmitter reliability. He does not strengthen a report merely because it has many routes, but assesses whether those routes can legitimately support one another. Topics include family and women, worship, etiquette, remembrances, spiritual exhortation, seasons, and historical stories. Reports examined include “Astrologers lie even when they are right,” “Son of Adam, I created you to worship Me, so do not play,” the supplication asking blessings in Rajab and Shaban and to reach Ramadan, sayings about marriage and gift-giving, the basmalah in ablution, and holiday greetings. The work aims to clarify commonly circulated reports and distinguish sound Sunnah from weak, false, and fabricated material, offering an authentic alternative where available. It combines source-tracing, narrator criticism, study of hidden defects, textual criticism, and correction of misconceptions.